Sunday, February 12, 2012

Corruption

The most difficult decision I have ever made involved witnessing a wrong occur against myself, my co-workers, and my community, and choosing not to address it. The wrong in this case was a mundane act of corruption and political maneuvering in a small African town. It involved dismantling a successful project to make the town’s tax records fair and accurate and replacing honest personnel with less-honest ones. I was involved in designing the project, and the personnel replaced were my friends and co-workers. While the decision to speak out against corruption appears simple enough, there were more complex considerations involved.

When I began working in the revenue department of the mayor’s office, I was unaware that I would face such a dilemma. I worked there because the system for managing the revenue of the town of 30,000 was inefficient. Cards with taxpayer information were left unsorted, and payments were marked in notebooks, with hundreds of lines of information totaled using a calculator. No audit could be performed, and it was effectively impossible to determine who owed back taxes.

The foe in this case was innocent- a lack of order and transparency. The tool to battle such a foe was computerization. After a few months of guided training the department employees were independently using an accounting system that I helped design.

The project was successful, but a year later it came to an abrupt end. A man named Pape Mbaye replaced my two trainees and friends, as they had replaced him years earlier. The computer they had been using was unplugged and pushed aside. The old notebooks were back.

Pape Mbaye’s arrival did not trouble me until I learned about the politics that fueled his return and the reasons for his initial dismissal. I learned that Pape Mbaye had originally been replaced due to irregularities with record-keeping and for having misallocated funds. While this would constitute a serious offense almost anywhere, the town’s decision-makers decided the best course of action was to reassign Pape Mbaye to a different post within the office. After all, there was no sense causing a scandal that would sully the reputation of the ruling party.

During my tenure working with Pape Mbaye I witnessed small, alarming events, including seeing money taken from the tax revenue drawer and given to personal visitors with no record kept. Over time I learned more troubling news. My former co-workers were being shunned due to their political affiliation. The year before there had been a split within the ruling political party, and they aligned with the faction that did not control the mayorship.

As the situation became clearer I examined the viable options at my disposal. I could confront the mayor or Pape Mbaye and privately raise my concerns. I could bring the situation to the attention of the city council, which could put pressure on the mayor. I could also contact the regional treasury bureau, which rested in different political hands.

Success was possible but not likely for each of these actions. A direct confrontation would be culturally offensive and at best would cause Pape Mbaye to temporarily yield and begin using the accounting program. Without direct personal supervision, however, he would have no incentive to continue. Raising the issue with the city council would make the situation public and at least lead to more scrutiny of the treasury. However, it was also a risky option, and depending on how politics played out my friends and former co-workers could potentially lose their jobs. Bringing the situation to light of the regional treasury would potentially be the most effective option. However, such a move, if successful, would disgrace the mayor’s office and would undermine the trust I would need to work effectively in the future with other organizations.

I judged how I would be perceived if I brought the issue to light, and I concluded that, as an outsider, I would be viewed with suspicion by those parties responsible for rectifying the situation. I also estimated the response of my former co-workers and program director. When I later contacted them for advice it surprised me to learn that they were neutral about intervention. I incorrectly predicted their response because I didn’t fully take into account their other responsibilities, including to their families and organizations.

I could not think of a perfect or practical solution, so instead, I considered my obligations. I had an obligation to help my friends and former co-workers. If I could not do this, I had an obligation not to harm them through my actions. I had an obligation to my work, but attempting to rescue this one project would have consumed time, resources and credibility increasingly being dedicated to a more ambitious schools project. I also had an obligation to support good governance. Nevertheless, I speculated whether my good intentions would lead to good outcomes.

Ultimately, I considered my organization’s directing principles, which stated simply that I was forbidden from becoming involved in politics. Though I could justify action on the grounds that corruption was separate from politics, I personally knew that political considerations were at play, and my actions would be viewed through a political lens.

Wednesday, October 17, 2007

Switzerld

andI went to Switzerland the other week. I was working on my computer, error testing the software program that I was working on for the past year, when I got a call from my work partner. “Would I like to go to Switzerland?” he asked. “Sure,” I said. And then we went, five days later.

The premise for the trip was that a UN conference on ICT, development, and youth was taking place in Geneva. My work partner and I had entered into a contest for IT projects, and we had written an article about the school management program we had created. Winners of the contest were announced a few months ago, with hearty congratulations and the promise of some unnamed prize. The unnamed prize, of course, hadn’t been thought up when the winners were chosen, so when a UN IT conference came up and volunteers were needed to spread the good word about PC, the prize suddenly crystallized into a trip to Switzerland, UN-funded stipend included.

The four-day UN stipend came out to approximately our salary for 4 months. Of course, that sum was blown through slumming it in Geneva, but that’s not the point. This is why I hate the UN. Something like half a million dollars was spent to draw up wording to a UN resolution including the participation of youth in the decision-making process of the UN’s IT development projects. The assembly was exactly like Model UN, only it was the real thing.

What to say of Switzerland? There are only a few places in the world that billionaires prefer to reside, and one of them is Geneva. But besides how expensive it is? How about the fact that you need reservations even to go. Switzerland is perhaps the only country in the world where you are forced by circumstances to spend a night in a homeless shelter, even though you have 400 dollars cash in your pocket. It is also perhaps the only country in the world where the nightly rate and clientele of said homeless shelter rivals that of an average Super8 motel in the States. If you really have you money, you will be kindly asked to leave the national borders and never come back.

Any list of Switzerland’s oddities could not possibly succeed in being definitive. I expected it to be more or less like any other European country I had visited; perhaps less rough around the edges, but similar in disposition. What, then, to say about a country that’s graffiti, scarce though it may be, carries slogans such as “Germans go home” or whose mainstream political posters depict six white sheep standing on a map of Switzerland and a black sheet being excluded with the slogan “Keep Switzerland pure”. When Germans form the top ranks of the underclass, you know something is wrong.

The Germans most certainly would go home if they didn’t earn so much being day laborers. That may also be said of the 25% of the country’s workforce who is not Swiss. Non-citizens face discrimination in a myriad of small ways- being forced to pay for drinks upfront in a bar; waiting eight months to rent an apartment; not being allowed to drive. The white collar imported workforce is treated equally poorly as the blue collar part. Executives earning 90,000 dollars a year, for example, get about the same going over as a poor North African in Paris. Which is not to say that the Swiss are openly discriminatory- that would go against their national values and political correctness! They are far too polite to overtly discriminate.

What are Swiss values, besides politeness and political correctness? It just became legal to beg on the street, so long as the proceeds are taxed accordingly. The problem with begging it’s a public nuisance, but that its offensive to the Protestant ethic. In a country where the super-rich are forcing the rich into middle-classdom, even those at the top feel guilt over hiring cleaning ladies.

The night before the last, we had met up with a refugee of Burundian royalty, who took us around town, We walked into the symphony, a high rise apartment complex, the law library of the university, even, for whatever reason, Smith College’s European campus, because people just assumed we had a good reason for being there. That, and a pleasant, conversational tone, will open just about any door you need. We visited the grave of John Calvin, noted father of Protestantism, in a well-kept cemetery in downtown Geneva. The noted father of Protestantism was celebrated in the afterlife by a three foot by five foot bush and a book-sized plaque.

That’s Swiss. If they wish to close every single store and shop on Sunday, no exception, that is their prerogative. If they wish to outlaw the use of washing machines after 10pm, so be it. Or, if they wish to impose a snack break at movies. Or, if they wish to not have price labels in grocery stores.

After a week of this, I was ready to return to Senegal, home of libertarianism in action. Goats roam the airport. The taxi drivers will not hesitate to grab you or your bags and shepherd you into their car, which, of course, meets no safety or emission standards whatsoever. We paid four dollars for a twenty-minute taxi ride back from the airport, over a dirt-filled, rubble strewn highway. I checked into the volunteer house around midnight, stepped over sleeping people, trash, and empty beer bottles, and set up a foam mattress in the backyard. I was woken the next day at dawn by the loudspeaker of the local mosque.

Senegal does have chaos, insanity, and mess, but the culture shock is not more taxing than anywhere else. After two years here, I come out looking no more worse for wear than my Polish cousin, working in the financial city of Zurich.

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

airport

I was recently at the airport with my friend. For those of you who have never visited that Dakar airport, I can say that it gives you a pretty accurate idea of what the country is like. The last time I was there, I was waiting for the bus and a pack of goats just walked by, a couple feet from the entrance. Never mind the beggars straying the entrance and the never-finished construction or the lack of working monitors relaying flight information, or the fact that the power went out. This post is not about the airport. It’s about corruption.

My Lebanese friend had a couple of friends visit from France, and for the occasion, he brought with him a roll of Euro notes. How big was the roll? Fat. For those of you wondering why he brought with him all this money, the fact is that it’s illegal to move more than $5,000 of money out of the country at any given time. But if you come into Senegal and declare your monetary bringings upon you’re arrival, why, it wouldn’t make sense that you would be allowed to go out with any less than you brought in. And if you could conveniently get your hands on a roll of euro notes, say, in the outside bathroom of the airport before going through the declaration section of customs, when you leave…

My friend did not have to bribe anyone to make the scheme work. Due to sheer laziness on the part of the authorities, you can leave the airport, come back, and then go through a customs declaration, which doesn’t matter anyways because the customs agents won’t bother to check the validity of the form.

The simple fact is that the capital controls are not in place due to corruption. They are a futile tool used to maintain fixed exchange rates, which is itself a futile policy that hasn’t been corrected in the 47 years since independence. Likewise, corruption didn’t do the airport in: forty years of mismanagement and poor planning did. So why do people blame corruption for Africa’s ills, instead of horrible policies and mismanagement?

Probably because Africa is corrupt, and corruption is “BAD”. Instead of thinking of corruption as a problem, for a change, let’s think of it as a solution.

Your building permit will take nine months just to be processed? Pay four hundred dollars and it’ll be done by the end of the week.

The grading system unfairly kicks students out of school? Nothing that can’t be settled with a twenty dollar payment to the proper administrator.

Don’t have insurance, a driver’s license, or proper vehicle registration? Vehicle very much unfit for passenger transport? Two dollars will get you out of a police checkpoint.

And so corruption flourishes. There are two types of corruption: paying to get something positive done and paying to prevent something bad from happening. The vast majority of the population sees neither of these forms. For them, corruption is essentially irrelevant, since they pay no taxes and will never demand any of the services facilitated through bribery.

Corruption exists because just about nobody wants to see corruption end. Paying to get something positive done is like paying an expedited fee to get a passport quickly; more cost, less hassle.

Paying to prevent something bad from happening is a form of insurance. For the average person, even the average business owner, the costs of paying bribes are so low in comparison to your salary that you simply get on with it. The costs of not paying are unknown but can wind up being heavy. Paying bribes is like paying for a home security system: the more people who do, the more likely that those who don’t will be targets. The more likely you are to be targeted, the more incentive you have to pay.

But nobody would pay unless public services weren’t so terrible to begin with. And public services are so terrible to begin with because public services have always been terrible, so nobody knows any better and nobody gets up in arms about it. Also, nobody pays taxes. Also, it’s impossible to fire anybody in the bureaucracy.

Then there is corruption on a national scale, the skimming from building projects, the misallocation of resources, and kleptocracy- state funds going into the pockets of those who manage them. All legal. In truth, the president has such constitution power that he is legally authorized to award contracts and spend a significant amount of money without any oversight. Technically, this isn’t corruption at all. But anyhow, better that officials be corrupt and competent than the reverse. And at the local level, is there really corruption if there are no rules for awarding contracts and the local deputies aren’t bothered that the town treasurer doesn’t keep records?

So if corruption isn’t the problem, what is?

The problem is that nobody really minds the goats roaming the airport parking lot enough to do something about it.

Sunday, July 22, 2007

Gambia

I’ve been travelling quite a bit recently, and not just to the usual haunts. So far this month I’ve been to a few big Senegalese cities and a foreign country. As usual, it’s been for work, work being a big hobby I have to occupy my time.

The first trip this month was to The Gambia. The Gambia is a foreign country that actually lies within Senegal. If you look on a map of the world, you will probably not even notice it. If you look closely at Senegal on a map of Africa might notice that there’s an area shaped like a worm jutting out of the center of the country. That’s the Gambia. There are approximately a million habitants of The Gambia and about a hundred Peace Corps volunteers, or, one per square mile.

As the crow flies, Banjul, the capital, is about a hundred and fifty miles away from my town. In a race to Banjul between myself and a crow, I would bet on the crow. Of course, the crow doesn’t have to wait in the garage two hours for a car to leave, doesn’t have to get out and walk to the border, doesn’t have to go through two sets of customs, doesn’t have to hire a taxi and drive a length down a “road”. If he did, though, I’d still bet on him. If the crow had to take a two hour ferry to cross a one mile stretch of the Gambia River, however I’d be inclined to bet on myself.

What can be said about Gambia as a country? It’s English-speaking. It’s green, and it rains there more so than up here, so there are palm trees everywhere, and the ground isn’t sand. It’s the poorest country on Earth that hasn’t been in a protracted civil war. Gambian teachers earn less than Senegalese maids. It’s a nice place for tourists, and the beaches and restaurants are nice. Also, the president has stated publicly that he can single-handedly cure AIDS. He’s used international criticism against him to launch a tirade against the West. Most Gambians believe him, though most Senegalese just shake their heads. “Why would he lie to us?” they say. Indeed.

The capital of The Gambia is a small town of 50,000, though most administrative functions are carried out in the suburbs, which are smaller. The US Embassy and PC headquarters are in Fajara, a sleepy tourist beach town that looks like it could be just about anywhere in the world. In bars you have a choice of Guinness or a local microbrew. Every year, the brewery throws a party for PC volunteers, who are their best customer.

The Gambia exists for pernicious reasons. In the 18th century the English and French were vying for control of the major waterways in west Africa. After a protracted conflict, the French ceded control of the Gambian River was for the strategically-located Goree Island, just off the coast of Dakar. Though only about a quarter of a square mile in area, Goree was then an important fortification, shipping and slave-trading post. Now it’s a UNESCO-protected site, with architecture reminiscent of southern France.

Gambia still exists for pernicious reasons. The brief union of the two countries in the 1980’s was dissolved after only a few years. Needless to say, politics and language were a factor, but not the only ones. Gambians feel that Senegalese are arrogant towards them, and the Senegalese feel that The Gambia is a nuisance. Both sides are right. Gambia’s chief port is much bigger than it should be- no surprise given that its customs are much lower than Senegal’s . Both Gambians and Senegalese make money engaging in arbitrage between the two countries. The Gambian government also generates a good deal of revenue charging Senegalese vehicles transport fees for traversing the country. Quite honestly, without red tape, The Gambia would have no economy. So in spite of good, logical reasons otherwise, the borders between the two countries are rather heavily regulated.

I’ve heard many political theorists state that from an economic perspective, African countries are too small. Still others state that they are too large, considering they consist of far too many adversarial ethnic groups. In either case, most argue that the current formations of African states are illogical and detrimental because their borders were arbitrarily drawn by Europeans. Such arguments are nonsense. Consider that the borders of every single country in the Americas are equally arbitrary, European constructions, their populations also ethnically mixed. Yet such arguments are not exclusively used to explain the political functionality or dysfunctionality of those countries.

Any way you slice the pie in Africa, you would run into the same problems. It would be impossible to create territories where ethnic groups are not intermixed, or even to separate adversarial groups, since they tend to be neighbors.

On the other hand, as of 2007, most Africans have developed rather strong national identities, based on common experiences within seemingly arbitrary borders. This is mainly soccer’s doing, but there are other shared experiences that count as well. Consider that all Senegalese are proud that their first president was a poet and Nobel laureate, and even that their capital was once the seat of a colonial empire. This has shaped national character as much as anything may. Any Senegalese can tell you what the difference between a Senegalese and an Ivoirian is. Ask anyone to describe Nigerians, and they’ll tell you in no uncertain terms.
National identities exist, and so must their national borders. The rationale of existence of Senegal and The Gambia is no lesser or greater than that of the United States and Canada. So why have African politics and African economies turned out the way they have?…

Sunday, July 15, 2007

Off to Louga

Hello all,
I’ve been travelling quite a bit recently, and not just to the usual haunts.

I recently returned from Louga, a city of 150,000 people. Louga is a regional capital about a hundred miles north of where I live. In size, stature, and situation, the city is just about average, which is probably why it was chosen for Jeffery Sachs’ Millenium Cities Project. The Millenium Cities Project is supposed to monitor and ensure that countries are meeting the Millenium Development Goals, the set of benchmarks in health, education, and so forth set by the UN for the year 2015. For those unfamiliar with Jeffrey Sachs, he’s an economist and recent champion of Africa in the media. He’s frequently in the company of Bono, a non-economist and other recent champion of Africa in the media.

Whenever I go to Louga I’m always struck by something in the atmosphere that depresses me a bit. It is mostly treeless, sandy, and rough around the edges, with a decaying grandiosity perhaps not intended by the local religious leader who planned its streets. Though Louga is just like everywhere else in Senegal, there is a greater sense there of biding time than almost anywhere else I’ve visited in country.

On visits I stay with the volunteer who lives and works there, in her room inside the compound of a large family. During lunch time, the whole family comes out to eat in a crowd of children, about six women, and exactly no men. The children are sent primarily from destitute relatives, who live poor in nearby villages. They are the product of uneducated girls, large families, pregnancies in teenage years, out of wedlock or to young men without jobs. The Louga family is obliged to open its doors and welcome any family member that wants a meal or a place to stay, but the family is too big to be responsible for everyone. The parents send their child away to the family in Louga, so they’re not responsible for these children either.

The women of the Louga family are all married. Their men are away, working in Dakar, New York, Italy, France, Spain. They are selling hand bags or laying bricks, earning enough money to feed a mass of children and support six women. Indeed, this is unexceptional. Families are large, and work is scarce. Emigration, with the right underground connections, is easy and visas are awarded seemingly without rhyme or reason.

Louga has some beautiful houses, paid for with money selling handbags or laying bricks. Louga, too, has beautiful girls, who won’t even think about marrying a man unless he’s working abroad or soon will be- or is about to be the father of a child. With little commerce, the town has many banks packed with people. The queues are in front of the Western Union or Moneygram booths. The ambition and money lay elsewhere, the women and children here.

But what else can you do? Work in the market for two dollars a day? Farm in a country that lacks rain 8 months of the year? Marry a farmer? Decisions are made either by parents in families who understand the realities of their situation, or by girls at sixteen who don’t.

Oftentimes, when journalists write about AIDS in Africa, they go to a local village and report that all they find there are children and the elderly. We are led to believe that AIDS has devastated the social fabric of this continent, emptying the villages of the young and able. But in reality, the villages have been emptying for decades, while at the same time filling with children and the elderly. Immigration, to the big cities and beyond, felled the village. Numerically, villages may now be larger, but they are smaller, less viable places to live.

Louga has everything that my town lacks- internet, restaurants, hotels- but it is fundamentally just a big village. My town is blessed to be a real town; the men have jobs and live with their families. Some commute long distances, some have factory jobs, some vend, and some work in offices. Some even make daily fortunes in Dakar and commute back at night. Of course, many work abroad, but some come home to start real enterprises. Wives who work choose to have two or three children, and send their kids go to school. There is everything else here, good and bad, that there is everywhere else in Senegal, but amazingly, people can make a real life under their feet.

Africa will develop when its citizens can make a life under their own feet; It will develop when men need not travel to do real work, teenage girls have something more to look forward to than getting married and having children young, and parents have a reason and the means to send their children to school. It will develop when large families no longer live off of the one who makes it, and every individual makes his own way in the world. There is nothing terribly unusual in all this- we see glimpses of it every day.

When I look at the country or the continent as a whole, the answers seem so simple. But when I look at individuals and how they’re living their lives, running their businesses, or raising their children, I’m at a loss as to what they could do better, how I can help them, or how anyone else can either. Undoubtedly, the Jeffrey Sachs’ and the Bonos of the world also have a solution for Africa. They must also certainly lack one for Africans.

The key to development, paradoxically, is development itself. The situation must change for the individual to change, and the individual must change for the situation to change. How this can happen is anybody’s guess.

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

good news

A wonderful thing happened the other day. My former neighbors, who moved away a year ago called me out of the blue and told me they had returned. They had moved again to a beach town on the road to Dakar, not too far away from my site. Diarra, the husband, was working a good plot of land, and they had a nice place to stay. His wife and their four kids were there as well.

This news was particularly welcoming. The last time I had seen them they had packed up shop and were heading to Kolda to live with family. I always considered the move a bit odd- rather akin to the Joad’s of the Grapes of Wrath moving to Oklahoma because things weren’t working out. My town is wealthier than just about anywhere else and has factories, water, and agriculture, prompting my supervisor to call it the California of Senegal. While this comparison should seem apt for those that have been here, I don’t want to give the wrong impression. The majority of people here are still very poor, and life is still hard. Nevertheless, Kolda, five hundred kilometers away, can best be described as primitive. There is no readily-accessable market, no factories, and no jobs. A great deal of the country is this way.

My former neighbors had a particularly affectionate place in my heart. The wife spoke French to me in the beginning and was always joking and talkative. The husband was trying to get by as a farmer, but couldn’t. I visited his plot one time when he was going to retrieve a water pump to sell in Dakar. His plot was four acres, shared with two other workers, lacking much water, the soil mostly sand. It was almost nothing, split three ways. The pump fed the family. The sum total of their possessions were four wooden chairs, a bed, a mattress, clothes and a few other small valuables. Even still, they made a point of never asking me for anything, even when they had literally no money.

When I went to visit them I was shocked to discover that they were living in a giant, modern house, with a view of the ocean, no less. The sister of the wife, who’s married to a Frenchman and living in France, had constructed a vacation beach house, and my former neighbors got to move in to oversee its construction and look after the place. They were doing OK.

Changing fortunes in Senegal are striking. Spouses die, factories close, and crops sometimes fail. Conversely, children go to work abroad, or other family members end up doing well. I had a client who lived in a neighboring village who was down and out after his store closed. During the final days it was impossible to work with him, and I could see the desperation of a man wondering how to support his wife, kids, and sick mother. I tried my hardest to help him, but couldn’t come up with anything. Once his boss closed up shop, I didn’t see him again.

One day a few months later I got an unexpected call. It was my former client, enthusiastic, happy, and doing fine. He had found employment as a driver working in mines in the far south of the country.

If there is one thing to understand about Senegal, it is this: Senegal is a poor country where people land on their feet even though life is tough. Just about everyone is trying to do the best they can. Families are big, and they help if possible. People may go hungry, but nobody starves.

Sunday, April 01, 2007

Roof

Hello all,

It’s been a while since I last posted because I couldn’t’ really think of anything exciting to write about. I went to America and came back. Upon my return I found myself more relaxed than I have been in a long, long time. Then I found out my roof was going to be replaced, and I flipped out and haven’t recovered since. Normally, this is not something that would upset me greatly, but the powers that be decided to tear up a perfectly good corrugated cement roof and replace it with corrugated metal. What’s the difference, you ask? Well, now my building is made out of the same materials as convection ovens and smelters. So it is hot, hot, hot inside- about five degrees more than it would otherwise be. And will the roof not leak, unlike the last one, built five years earlier?

After barring the workers from entering my building, I reluctantly opened the door and showed the foreman my concerns with the structural problems. No problem, he says. We fix things like this all the time. Your roof won’t leak, “n’shallah” (God willing), which is another way of saying who knows. This, of course, was an unacceptable answer, which I brought to my host mom’s attention in the form of aggravated screaming.

“What about the structural problems? I have no confidence at all that they’ll fix it.”

“This is Senegal, this isn’t America. This guy is a professional. I wouldn’t’ hire just anyone to do the job,” was her response.

I briefly accepted this answer until I saw the workers crookedly nailing new sheets to my roof with rocks.

I couldn’t help feeling that the whole exercise is a parable for the woes of development projects. In essence a lot of money was spent to change something that didn’t work properly, only to replace it with something worse. If a five year-old had designed my roof, i.e. made it triangular and downward sloping, this whole mess would have been avoided. Instead, someone had to get fancy, and cheap, and combined with the fact that no measurements were taken before materials were either cut or placed or lengths nailed in, well, you can imagine. And instead of doing a better job the second time around, the fix was just as shoddy as the original job, only more time and effort was wasted correcting the original work.

I shut up and gave in, seeing that the workers had already torn up a good portion of the old roof. And now, the new one is in place. Given the fact that the corners were sealed up essentially with mud and the nails holding the segments to the support beams were stopped with cut up pieces of flip flop, I feel justified in moving out if the damn thing doesn’t hold.