Sunday, February 12, 2012

Corruption

The most difficult decision I have ever made involved witnessing a wrong occur against myself, my co-workers, and my community, and choosing not to address it. The wrong in this case was a mundane act of corruption and political maneuvering in a small African town. It involved dismantling a successful project to make the town’s tax records fair and accurate and replacing honest personnel with less-honest ones. I was involved in designing the project, and the personnel replaced were my friends and co-workers. While the decision to speak out against corruption appears simple enough, there were more complex considerations involved.

When I began working in the revenue department of the mayor’s office, I was unaware that I would face such a dilemma. I worked there because the system for managing the revenue of the town of 30,000 was inefficient. Cards with taxpayer information were left unsorted, and payments were marked in notebooks, with hundreds of lines of information totaled using a calculator. No audit could be performed, and it was effectively impossible to determine who owed back taxes.

The foe in this case was innocent- a lack of order and transparency. The tool to battle such a foe was computerization. After a few months of guided training the department employees were independently using an accounting system that I helped design.

The project was successful, but a year later it came to an abrupt end. A man named Pape Mbaye replaced my two trainees and friends, as they had replaced him years earlier. The computer they had been using was unplugged and pushed aside. The old notebooks were back.

Pape Mbaye’s arrival did not trouble me until I learned about the politics that fueled his return and the reasons for his initial dismissal. I learned that Pape Mbaye had originally been replaced due to irregularities with record-keeping and for having misallocated funds. While this would constitute a serious offense almost anywhere, the town’s decision-makers decided the best course of action was to reassign Pape Mbaye to a different post within the office. After all, there was no sense causing a scandal that would sully the reputation of the ruling party.

During my tenure working with Pape Mbaye I witnessed small, alarming events, including seeing money taken from the tax revenue drawer and given to personal visitors with no record kept. Over time I learned more troubling news. My former co-workers were being shunned due to their political affiliation. The year before there had been a split within the ruling political party, and they aligned with the faction that did not control the mayorship.

As the situation became clearer I examined the viable options at my disposal. I could confront the mayor or Pape Mbaye and privately raise my concerns. I could bring the situation to the attention of the city council, which could put pressure on the mayor. I could also contact the regional treasury bureau, which rested in different political hands.

Success was possible but not likely for each of these actions. A direct confrontation would be culturally offensive and at best would cause Pape Mbaye to temporarily yield and begin using the accounting program. Without direct personal supervision, however, he would have no incentive to continue. Raising the issue with the city council would make the situation public and at least lead to more scrutiny of the treasury. However, it was also a risky option, and depending on how politics played out my friends and former co-workers could potentially lose their jobs. Bringing the situation to light of the regional treasury would potentially be the most effective option. However, such a move, if successful, would disgrace the mayor’s office and would undermine the trust I would need to work effectively in the future with other organizations.

I judged how I would be perceived if I brought the issue to light, and I concluded that, as an outsider, I would be viewed with suspicion by those parties responsible for rectifying the situation. I also estimated the response of my former co-workers and program director. When I later contacted them for advice it surprised me to learn that they were neutral about intervention. I incorrectly predicted their response because I didn’t fully take into account their other responsibilities, including to their families and organizations.

I could not think of a perfect or practical solution, so instead, I considered my obligations. I had an obligation to help my friends and former co-workers. If I could not do this, I had an obligation not to harm them through my actions. I had an obligation to my work, but attempting to rescue this one project would have consumed time, resources and credibility increasingly being dedicated to a more ambitious schools project. I also had an obligation to support good governance. Nevertheless, I speculated whether my good intentions would lead to good outcomes.

Ultimately, I considered my organization’s directing principles, which stated simply that I was forbidden from becoming involved in politics. Though I could justify action on the grounds that corruption was separate from politics, I personally knew that political considerations were at play, and my actions would be viewed through a political lens.